Knuckles point about mafia potentially being early voters is actually a decent one. With the pressure to bandwagon for scares, mafia have incentive to try and control the conversation early.
Sorry if that was obvious to everyone, it just clicked for me on a re-read.
Knuckles point about mafia potentially being early voters is actually a decent one. With the pressure to bandwagon for scares, mafia have incentive to try and control the conversation early.
Sorry if that was obvious to everyone, it just clicked for me on a re-read.
which is ironic, because Knuckles was the first to vote today.
Knuckles point about mafia potentially being early voters is actually a decent one. With the pressure to bandwagon for scares, mafia have incentive to try and control the conversation early.
Sorry if that was obvious to everyone, it just clicked for me on a re-read.
which is ironic, because Knuckles was the first to vote today.
Actually, you are. Knuckles pointed to two possible targets, but has yet to vote for anybody
+1
Options
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
I'm not convinced that I need to switch off of H3 just yet. His post was the first after results, which means he was watching intently and ready to pounce with an analysis, which is something I've done when I've been mafia.
I missed the vote close by about half an hour, stuck around to update my spreadsheet when the results were posted, then posted my speculation. As mrpaku correctly noted, I have not yet voted today. If what I've done seems to you like mafia behavior, I'll let you in on a little secret about how I play phalla:
For the record, I followed up on Knuckle's speculation with my LostNinja vote because I'd separately heard LostNinja's name come up as possibly suspicious from a different source, shortly after the vote last night
Two players separately pointing in LostNinja's direction as possible Mafia is much more than the *nothing* I've had to go on the previous two nights, even if both people pointing the finger end up being wrong (possibly moreso, although obviously I understand if LostNinja doesn't feel that way about things)
I voted today! You should def vote! Don't make GG sad!
0
Options
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Buh, looking over my voting records again, Lost and Raiden both have perfectly plausible self-preservation justifications for one of the two days. I'm not really feeling any of the current crop, to be honest. I mean, I'm obviously biased towards Brody given how he came out swinging for me. Phyphor's been pretty quiet but he's been like that most of the games I've played with him so I really don't know if that signifies anything. Which leaves JayKaos because...?
I guess I'll just go on the counter-attack and say Romantic Undead for not really contributing much other than accusations and asking people to mount a defense for me? Conversely, kime was being helpful with trying to extrapolate on roles and abilities from the days' results.
I'm happy leaning with both RU and knuckles likely being village.
I will say that I'm curious about the missing vig kill. Inactive? Roleblock? Or a voluntary abstention? Which isn't the craziest thing to have happen.
Does anybody have an updated player list handy?
The narration for day 2 said the vig didn't attempt anything, and we had several inactives day 2, either seems more probable than interference by players to me.
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Currently my count says there's a tie between Romantic Undead and Phyphor for 3 votes each. Anyone want to weigh in on which way they think it should go? Only an hour left and the following players have yet to vote AFAIK:
Not that I disagree with my previous position or feel swayed by any of the new ones, but not gonna lie
Joining the winning team and ginning up that third scare, despite however it may read to the peanut gallery afterwards, is getting reeeeaal tempting this evening
Posts
Sorry if that was obvious to everyone, it just clicked for me on a re-read.
which is ironic, because Knuckles was the first to vote today.
Actually, you are. Knuckles pointed to two possible targets, but has yet to vote for anybody
I missed the vote close by about half an hour, stuck around to update my spreadsheet when the results were posted, then posted my speculation. As mrpaku correctly noted, I have not yet voted today. If what I've done seems to you like mafia behavior, I'll let you in on a little secret about how I play phalla:
I will say that I'm curious about the missing vig kill. Inactive? Roleblock? Or a voluntary abstention? Which isn't the craziest thing to have happen.
Does anybody have an updated player list handy?
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
That's the whole game though!
Brody
Two players separately pointing in LostNinja's direction as possible Mafia is much more than the *nothing* I've had to go on the previous two nights, even if both people pointing the finger end up being wrong (possibly moreso, although obviously I understand if LostNinja doesn't feel that way about things)
H3Knuckles -1 (Romantic Undead)
Raiden -1 (Chamberlain)
LostNinja- 1 (mrpaku)
Romantic Undead -1 (Brody)
JayKaos- 1 (bluecyan)
Phyphor- 1 (LostNinja)
Brody- 1 (Virgil Leads You)
Quite the spread, ladies and gentlemen. Anyone else sense trickery afoot?
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
It even would appear to be a trap, but for whom.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
Very much doubt that's going to happen, in a bit we'll see the votes start pouring in.
I am busy today, but I don't mind doing that!
Knuckles
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I guess I'll just go on the counter-attack and say Romantic Undead for not really contributing much other than accusations and asking people to mount a defense for me? Conversely, kime was being helpful with trying to extrapolate on roles and abilities from the days' results.
1. kime
2. chamberlain
3. Phyphor
4. JayKaos
5. MrTLicious
6. AustinP0027 Always Bet On Red
7. Virgil_Leads_You
8. Sir Fabulous
9. LostNinja
10. Brody
11. JPants
12. Romantic Undead
13. CesareB Fashionable Late
14. Egos Wore The Wrong Mask
15. H3Knuckles
16. Preda He Wasn't Good Enough Boy
17. jdarksun Sugar Rush
18. KetBra Stuffed
19. lonelyahava
20. Spoit Is A Drop In The Bucket
21. Bluecyan
22. Auralynx
23. mrpaku
24. Raiden333
25. Cythraul
The narration for day 2 said the vig didn't attempt anything, and we had several inactives day 2, either seems more probable than interference by players to me.
Why are we not all bandwagoning someone random and then having everyone seer people in some kind of coordinated fashion?
There are items that let you become a thrall/miller, wouldn't that go counter to this plan?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
They will run out of scares presumably.
We don't know how they get scares, or if that's the only way to get gifts.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
2 bandwagon days per seer / thrall unless we randomly land on a mafia target seems less than effective to me at least.
I've given up suggesting crazy plans like that, they never work anyway
Joining the winning team and ginning up that third scare, despite however it may read to the peanut gallery afterwards, is getting reeeeaal tempting this evening
MrTs post is exactly he kind I would hate to see as mafia (been on the bad end of that before) so I guess Phyphor
!phyphor
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
vote !Phyphor
"Forget it, Jake... It's Halloweentown."