I've thought gelato 'bout this and I figured a random number generator is the way to go for the first vote especially since I have no preconceived notions of definitely mafia Frozen Dairy Dessert, so I'm going to go with what the RNG said and vote Wildcat
Generally, you have to vote every day including the first. Yes, that does mean the first day will be pretty random usually, but there's still sometimes good info to glean.
Yes, because otherwise we would have no start to vote information to analyze. Generally we're given one vote skip before being killed for inactivity, and you could use that to skip a specific vote. But that means you're at risk for life or just a simple brain fart killing you. And, at least for me, I feel that the ethical thing to do is vote every day.
Onto the Phalla itself, 21 players with an ideal of 25, so probably 4 mafia, maybe 5. Vanilla statements and roles along with the small population means that the mafia probably doesn't have a 2nd kill (or vig of their own). Serial killer is currently a big ?, but we'll know in a day.
So, without SK or 2nd mafia kill, we're probably looking at 3 per day (vote, vig, mafia), which would make for a 7 day minimum, and a 10ish day maximum. This is a reasonable time frame for a Phalla. Another kill would drop us to 5-10 days. Also reasonable. I think at 5 kills, the time would be 4-10 days, and I think the game could end too fast. The top end is unchanged because it's possible to lose all extra kill roles on day 1, even if very unlikely.
Phyphor developed a vote scraper at one point. It is still active? Or do we need to track our own vote totals?
I don't have the time right now to do the vote tracking again, but I can tell folks that people seemed to really like the bar chart race, if you can swing one.
Also go ahead and vote for me, I'm not gonna last long surely.
0
Options
38thDoelets never be stupid againwait lets always be stupid foreverRegistered Userregular
Posts
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Lots of newbies this game.
Players:
Kime
H3Knuckles
discrider
heffling
mrpaku
joshofalltrades
lostninja
Wildcat
PhoenixD
Infidel
38thDoe
enlightenedbum
jokerman
m!ttens
Gizzy
locus
justiceforpluto
Zombie Hero
Virgil_Leads_You
A midnight over here shout out to Mrpaku
Rad to play another game with ya.
Infidel's initial silence during the traditional icecream anthem troubles me. Not sure they are a team player.
And here I was thinking it was going to be about the board software to start ...
Steam: Elvenshae // PSN: Elvenshae // WotC: Elvenshae
Wilds of Aladrion: [https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/comment/43159014/#Comment_43159014]Ellandryn[/url]
i feel like i haven't voted for ebum in a while, and kime / infidel is a terrible cliche.
Oh wait, this is Infidel[color] pretending to be a vanillager instead of an icy whatever not ice-cream person.
Virgil_Leads_You so I don't forget.
@lonelyahava What time in UTC does the vote close?
He knows what he did.
What did he do?!
Island Name: Felinefine
And I'd do it again if I have the chance!
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
Generally, you have to vote every day including the first. Yes, that does mean the first day will be pretty random usually, but there's still sometimes good info to glean.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Yes, because otherwise we would have no start to vote information to analyze. Generally we're given one vote skip before being killed for inactivity, and you could use that to skip a specific vote. But that means you're at risk for life or just a simple brain fart killing you. And, at least for me, I feel that the ethical thing to do is vote every day.
Onto the Phalla itself, 21 players with an ideal of 25, so probably 4 mafia, maybe 5. Vanilla statements and roles along with the small population means that the mafia probably doesn't have a 2nd kill (or vig of their own). Serial killer is currently a big ?, but we'll know in a day.
So, without SK or 2nd mafia kill, we're probably looking at 3 per day (vote, vig, mafia), which would make for a 7 day minimum, and a 10ish day maximum. This is a reasonable time frame for a Phalla. Another kill would drop us to 5-10 days. Also reasonable. I think at 5 kills, the time would be 4-10 days, and I think the game could end too fast. The top end is unchanged because it's possible to lose all extra kill roles on day 1, even if very unlikely.
Phyphor developed a vote scraper at one point. It is still active? Or do we need to track our own vote totals?
Island Name: Felinefine
m!ttens
Steam: Elvenshae // PSN: Elvenshae // WotC: Elvenshae
Wilds of Aladrion: [https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/comment/43159014/#Comment_43159014]Ellandryn[/url]
I regret nothing!
Actually it hasn't worked even when he was playing for years. So much for the march of progress.
discrider 2- H3Knuckles, Gizzy
Infidel 2- Virgil, discrider
kime 1- Phoenix-D
enlightened bum 1- Lucedes
Virgil 1- Heffling
Zombie Hero 1- Locus
H3Knuckles 1- LostNinja
Wildcat 1- m!ttens
m!ttens 1- Elvenshae
Still haven't picked one of our thirty-one, errr, twenty-one delicious flavors: Kime, MrPaku, joshofalltrades, Wildcat, Infidel, 38thDoe, enlightened bum, Jokerman, Justice for Pluto, Zombie Hero
Probably a big ol' pile of Gummy Worms: Heffling
also for XOing kime so he could ???
I could also vote for kime.
More interesting is that someone else clearly got my gelato flavour and so I'm getting my spoons ready.
Also go ahead and vote for me, I'm not gonna last long surely.
Certainly not helping with checks or stopping the ship from exploding!
Then the entire red deck is useless, and pilots a trap.
Sure seems fun.
Nothing personal!
!discrider
Hopefully I'm not a fucking dumb dumb this time.
Not on my watch!
!Infidel