shalmelo, your not convinced I'm mafia but are voting for me because my vote record is bad.
guess what players put a ton of stock into making sure their voting record is as clean as possible? mafia
as a villager I want to spur discussion as much as possible and could really care less about my vote record.
look at ALL the evidence and tell me you really think I'm mafia.
It's not your vote record, plenty of people have bad vote records. It's the fact that you argued against the T_A bandwagon on day 2 AND the Iron Weasel bandwagon on day 3.
Which would be mildly dumb for a mafia member, to be fair. But it's a better lead for today than anything else I've seen as yet.
so you do think he might be mafia but you just are now owning up to it ;-) ?
Personally the only person I think I have a clear read on this game is Obi, who is being his accusatory village-self vs.
I normally don't do vote for people repeatedly but with Turanos's post and Buddha's post against the IW wagon from yesterday. I think Buddha is probably the best lead since it'll clear up a few things.
I don't trust Turanos, but the circumstances, it's possible that he did get shot since multiple people could draw a bead on him and he just panicked. On the other hand, he could be lying about getting shot because he is a dirty alien sympathizer.
apparently @Turanos, you were in my line of sight. Not that I think we should rule out other possibilities but it is possible I shot you without knowing it.
just to avoid unnecessary witch hunts, not that it should also be taken into consideration that the mafia could use a panicked person as cover for their own actions. Other things should obviously be taken into consideration.
I'm still curious about Buddha74 's odd comment last night , it strikes me as something ridiculously stupid for a mafioso to say but at the same time that he never responded back with his reasons makes me a little "O-o" ....and he isn't a vet. It strikes me he may have gotten advice to stay quiet, on the other-hand it was Friday.
Still strikes me as weird and some information is gained based on the number of votes that have been on him. So best I have atm.
your half right Egos. it was friday. second i should have edited that post because i lost my train of thought in the middle of typing and just voted. i was gonna vote chisauar11 last night for the fact that he hasn't moved even once this whole game, but i forgot his name and did feel like going back a page to find it. i was comfortable with voting Iron Weasel for the simple fact that I'm not huge fan of bandwagons and 75% of the time the person comes up villager. Also just so you know other then talking to my squad leader on the thread, I've spoken to anyone in my squad because i made a mistake moves Day 1 and have been out of range.
I'm going to vote Mill . i don't like it when the same person votes against me again and again without even given a real reason. I hope that satisfies everone's issues dealing with me.
At least one person in each of those groups is presumably mafia, which makes things sorta-easier. I'd guess there are 6 of them total, which would be a little high but not unreasonable. This doesn't help us figure out who they are, and neither does checking distribution vs. the player list, which I initially thought it might, but having done the work I'm putting it out there.
just double checking, is this is mostly correct? Peccavi is in my squad so that was one error.
obviously Auralynx's group is correct, and I corrected mine. The middle might have some mistakes or no?
It may, I was guessing from grid positions on the assumption that it really is a 6 / 6 / 7 / 7 split. It's still a reasonable thing to be updating, so thanks!
I'm guessing this has been theorized or mentioned before, but double checked my self. IW was in R24 and T_A was in R25 , so it is possible that the mafia is restricted in the same way we are. (e.g. the two discussed things as he was being voted off). If either missed the clarification of vote> all actions , it could explain things...
Granted still more likely they have a "psychic " link for balance, but you never know. so food for thought in the future.
0
Options
AuralynxDarkness is a perspectiveWatching the ego workRegistered Userregular
Could be, or they were ganging up to be up to no good at a future date using said psychic link. It's unclear at present.
Also, seriously, shoot some aliens, east guys. We're working our end of the problem over here.
I was initially with Trust's group. Day 1 I put in my orders before I saw Trust telling us to fall back, and after that it looked like I was closer to the action (and more likely to be a Badass) where I was, and they've totally got that back wall covered.
yeah, I'm just putting out theories because i figure I will be dead after tonight . considering an alien has me in sight and I can't do shit. It in theory could work if they thought T_A would be blamed....(e.g. they were lazy).
0
Options
AuralynxDarkness is a perspectiveWatching the ego workRegistered Userregular
Nah, keep spitballing. We still don't have a good handle on what's going on, we've just been reasonably lucky / had good instincts.
Really that post was just really suspicious. Someone hit a bunch of villagers with a grenade, arguing against voting for the most logical thrower really doesn't make sense. Really.
0
Options
ObiFettUse the ForceAs You WishRegistered Userregular
Really that post was just really suspicious. Someone hit a bunch of villagers with a grenade, arguing against voting for the most logical thrower really doesn't make sense. Really.
buddah, though obi is still being awfully reactionary. And I don't think there are even any facts wrong this time to piss him off?
The facts weren't off, but the reasoning was weird.
"His vote record is really horrible and keeps defending the what turns out to be mafia." is bad reasoning because that is not something a mafia actual does.
Assuming I was in ahead of just about everyone with my orders and didn't suffer an untimely demise. I should; hopefully, be at V2 in overwatch. Also since I should be close enough for my medkit to be worth a damn before a horrible death, assuming I'm still around today. I can provide heals to anyone in my squad that needs them.
Posts
so you do think he might be mafia but you just are now owning up to it ;-) ?
Personally the only person I think I have a clear read on this game is Obi, who is being his accusatory village-self vs.
granted he could be learning...
Obi is always angry.
Egos
Just shoot the alien in our row. Hopefully we can combine to kill it.
I don't trust Turanos, but the circumstances, it's possible that he did get shot since multiple people could draw a bead on him and he just panicked. On the other hand, he could be lying about getting shot because he is a dirty alien sympathizer.
battletag: Millin#1360
Nice chart to figure out how honest a news source is.
Or he got shot and is just telling the truth, because in most cases that is the smart thing to do regardless of alignment.
your half right Egos. it was friday. second i should have edited that post because i lost my train of thought in the middle of typing and just voted. i was gonna vote chisauar11 last night for the fact that he hasn't moved even once this whole game, but i forgot his name and did feel like going back a page to find it. i was comfortable with voting Iron Weasel for the simple fact that I'm not huge fan of bandwagons and 75% of the time the person comes up villager. Also just so you know other then talking to my squad leader on the thread, I've spoken to anyone in my squad because i made a mistake moves Day 1 and have been out of range.
I'm going to vote Mill . i don't like it when the same person votes against me again and again without even given a real reason. I hope that satisfies everone's issues dealing with me.
I love this post
if so
Squad 1
Egos
Megafrost
Mill
Vertroue
Turanos
Trust
Peccavi
Squad 2
Flarne- to be replaced?
Segatai
Assuran
Shalmelo
Iron Weasel
Obifett
Squad 3
MikeyCTS REG Rysk
Cythraul
kime
The Anonymous
SlyM
jdarksun
Squad 4
Auralynx
undergroundmonorail
GrimmyToA
enlightenedbum
Chiasaur
Buddha74
Spoit
obviously Auralynx's group is correct, and I corrected mine. The middle might have some mistakes or no?
Dunalist:
Buddha
Turanos
Chiasaur
Peccavi
Buddhawagon looks like it's gathering some steam, and I'm totally okay with that. Also, it's Saturday night and I'm going out now so...
It may, I was guessing from grid positions on the assumption that it really is a 6 / 6 / 7 / 7 split. It's still a reasonable thing to be updating, so thanks!
Mill.
I don't like the way Assuran just voted.
Meaning the complete lack of reasoning and the totally useless "for now" tacked on at the end.
Granted still more likely they have a "psychic " link for balance, but you never know. so food for thought in the future.
Also, seriously, shoot some aliens, east guys. We're working our end of the problem over here.
Got your back next round, Spoit.
Because I think the Buddha vote is incorrect.
SLyM makes a good point with the Assuran vote
Is this directed at me?
The facts weren't off, but the reasoning was weird.
"His vote record is really horrible and keeps defending the what turns out to be mafia." is bad reasoning because that is not something a mafia actual does.
Still missing votes from the following
@Vertroue
@Trust
@SeGaTai
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
In this case? Yeah?
Because courage is easy when there is no threat of danger.
I'm pretty satisfied with my play.
You aren't actually that close to being voted out are you?
battletag: Millin#1360
Nice chart to figure out how honest a news source is.