The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Once Upon A Time In...YaYa and Goose!’s Oscar Thread [YAYA WINS! PARASITE WINS!]
Oscars 2020! new thread, no hosts, maybe Parasite can win!
Here is the link to the form for the pool, entries close at 3:30PM PST on February 8th, a day before the ceremony. EDIT: pool closed! may the odds etc etc etc
we'll be collecting prizes up until February 8th, for now: @Goose! and I can announce that we’ll be offering six months of AMC A-List as a prize!
feel free to offer any and all prizes to the pool, and talk about how pissed you’ll be when Parasite doesn’t win anything other than Best Foreign Film before the nominations drop!
The Academy probably feels like they nominated Black Panther and gave Best Picture to Green Book so now they're good for about 5 years of just white movies, because they're old racist fucks.
+2
Raijin QuickfootI'm your Huckleberry YOU'RE NO DAISYRegistered User, ClubPAregular
I know Joker caused a lot of controversy but isn't is pretty regarded as a VERY well made and acted movie and shouldn't the nomination not really be a big surprise?
Also they probably feel like nominating Jojo Rabbit and Parasite checks the diversity box and well they already liked Get Out so it's not like they can like a second Jordan Peele movie now
I know Joker caused a lot of controversy but isn't is pretty regarded as a VERY well made and acted movie and shouldn't the nomination not really be a big surprise?
Sure but the main problem is it’s more opportunity for Todd Phillips to share his incredibly stupid and wrong opinions about everything
Captain Inertia on
0
Raijin QuickfootI'm your Huckleberry YOU'RE NO DAISYRegistered User, ClubPAregular
I know Joker caused a lot of controversy but isn't is pretty regarded as a VERY well made and acted movie and shouldn't the nomination not really be a big surprise?
Sure but the main problem is it’s more opportunity for Todd Phillips to share his incredibly stupid and wrong opinions about everything
I'm not trying to defend the movie or anything, I still haven't seen it. I'm just saying that it probably shouldn't be a surprise that it got so many nominations.
I know Joker caused a lot of controversy but isn't is pretty regarded as a VERY well made and acted movie and shouldn't the nomination not really be a big surprise?
Not really
it had early hype but it has a 59% on Metacritic. 30 positive reviews, 15, mixed and 12 negative
I know Joker caused a lot of controversy but isn't is pretty regarded as a VERY well made and acted movie and shouldn't the nomination not really be a big surprise?
Not really. 69% positive reviews on Rotten Tomatoes. Metascore of 59 on Metacritic. Not exactly universal critical acclaim.
For comparison, Knives Out is at 97 and 82, and Parasite is at 99 and 96. Little Women is at 95 and 91.
This many noms for Joker feels more like "It made a billion dollars, we should recognize it."
There is basically no communication between film critics, the Academy, and general audiences. Just three completely separate audiences with completely incompatible tastes.
The Academy probably feels like they nominated Black Panther and gave Best Picture to Green Book so now they're good for about 5 years of just white movies, because they're old racist fucks.
Wasn't Green Book also basically a white movie since it apparently had changes to actual events that made the driver look better and was done without the consent of the musician's family?
Madican on
+4
Raijin QuickfootI'm your Huckleberry YOU'RE NO DAISYRegistered User, ClubPAregular
Moonlight is the token Academy pick.
They gave Moonlight best pic so they don't have to worry about minorities for at least ten years.
+4
3cl1ps3I will build a labyrinth to house the cheeseRegistered Userregular
The Academy probably feels like they nominated Black Panther and gave Best Picture to Green Book so now they're good for about 5 years of just white movies, because they're old racist fucks.
Wasn't Green Book also basically a white movie since it apparently had changes to actual events that made the driver look better and was done without the consent of the musician's family?
The Academy probably feels like they nominated Black Panther and gave Best Picture to Green Book so now they're good for about 5 years of just white movies, because they're old racist fucks.
Wasn't Green Book also basically a white movie since it apparently had changes to actual events that made the driver look better and was done without the consent of the musician's family?
Sure was.
It rewrote a real person into a stereotype to create the narrative of the stiff, overly cultured black man learning to appreciate his own culture from his salt-of-the-earth working class driver. None of the relationships in the movie existed as depicted, the subject of the movie was adamant that he did not want Hollywood touching his life story, and the white POV character's real life counterpart was not only not a friend but someone who got fired and was largely forgotten until he sold the rights to "their" life story.
Even by the slippery standards of Hollywood biopics, it was pretty bad.
+5
AtomicTofuShe's a straight-up supervillain, yoRegistered Userregular
In light of Greta Gerwig not getting nominated for directing Little Women I was like, "fuck and they didn't even nominate her for directing Lady Bird either," but they uh, did, and then I was like, "I bet she should have fuckin' won that year too!" and then I got a look at the other nominees and that was a legitimately good year for the category, like, Jordan Peele and Guillermo del Toro are in there!
and then I got mad that Allison Janney won instead of Laurie Metcalf again, smh
In light of Greta Gerwig not getting nominated for directing Little Women I was like, "fuck and they didn't even nominate her for directing Lady Bird either," but they uh, did, and then I was like, "I bet she should have fuckin' won that year too!" and then I got a look at the other nominees and that was a legitimately good year for the category, like, Jordan Peele and Guillermo del Toro are in there!
and then I got mad that Allison Janney won instead of Laurie Metcalf again, smh
I haven't really paid much attention to the Oscars in the past. Right not it seems like the consensus is that Greta Gerwig got snubbed for best director. I think Little Women in one of the best movies I've seen this year so my inclination is to agree, but it did get nominated for Best Picture. Generally what is the line that makes a movie Best Picture worthy, but not best director, or vice versa? I'm mostly curious in what would a director need to do for their movie to legitimately deserve a Best Picture nomination, but not a Best Director nomination.
I know Cats withdrew from the statues but I was looking forward to being outraged at Jennifer Hudson getting snubbed by the Taylor Swift and Idris Elba sex duet.
Posts
1917
Parasite
The Lighthouse
Little Women
The Irishman
Uncut Gems
Doctor Sleep
Once Upon A Time In Hollywood
https://www.indiewire.com/2020/01/2020-oscar-nominations-list-academy-awards-joker-parasite-1202201829/amp/
we’ll have the form up soon!
We sure do live in a society.
If I'm doing the form it'll be not till tonight. My current job isn't like my old one I have zero free time
Oh well, rooting for Parasite, expecting 1917 (ugh) or The Irishmen (which I haven't seen but I'm sure is excellent).
Joker ties for most Oscar wins for a film
Steam ID XBL: JohnnyChopsocky PSN:Stud_Beefpile WiiU:JohnnyChopsocky
Sure but the main problem is it’s more opportunity for Todd Phillips to share his incredibly stupid and wrong opinions about everything
I'm not trying to defend the movie or anything, I still haven't seen it. I'm just saying that it probably shouldn't be a surprise that it got so many nominations.
Not really
it had early hype but it has a 59% on Metacritic. 30 positive reviews, 15, mixed and 12 negative
Average/mixed score overall
Not really. 69% positive reviews on Rotten Tomatoes. Metascore of 59 on Metacritic. Not exactly universal critical acclaim.
For comparison, Knives Out is at 97 and 82, and Parasite is at 99 and 96. Little Women is at 95 and 91.
This many noms for Joker feels more like "It made a billion dollars, we should recognize it."
Too bad about Uncut Gems being shut-out and Knives Out only getting a single nom tho
Not being subtle with the racism this year.
Wasn't Green Book also basically a white movie since it apparently had changes to actual events that made the driver look better and was done without the consent of the musician's family?
They gave Moonlight best pic so they don't have to worry about minorities for at least ten years.
Sure was.
It rewrote a real person into a stereotype to create the narrative of the stiff, overly cultured black man learning to appreciate his own culture from his salt-of-the-earth working class driver. None of the relationships in the movie existed as depicted, the subject of the movie was adamant that he did not want Hollywood touching his life story, and the white POV character's real life counterpart was not only not a friend but someone who got fired and was largely forgotten until he sold the rights to "their" life story.
Even by the slippery standards of Hollywood biopics, it was pretty bad.
Steam
and then I got mad that Allison Janney won instead of Laurie Metcalf again, smh
I haven't really paid much attention to the Oscars in the past. Right not it seems like the consensus is that Greta Gerwig got snubbed for best director. I think Little Women in one of the best movies I've seen this year so my inclination is to agree, but it did get nominated for Best Picture. Generally what is the line that makes a movie Best Picture worthy, but not best director, or vice versa? I'm mostly curious in what would a director need to do for their movie to legitimately deserve a Best Picture nomination, but not a Best Director nomination.
and also Once Upon a Time in Hollywood might be Tarantino's single weakest film, honestly